Group vs ICHRA Cost Comparison | Accurate Health Plans
ICHRA Employer Information

Want to Learn More About ICHRA?

Get more in-depth information about how ICHRA works, employer contributions, employee eligibility, the 11 employee classes, compliance requirements, and more.

Start With a Simple ICHRA Review

You do not have to decide whether to change plans. First, let us determine whether ICHRA is even worth a closer look for your business.

EMPLOYER REVIEW FORM PLACEHOLDER

Company · Contact · Phone · Email
Number of Employees · Current Group Plan
Current Employer Contribution · Renewal Date
Before You Accept the Renewal

Your Group Renewal Does Not Have to Be the Only Number You Consider.

Most employers know what their current group plan costs. What they often do not know is what the same benefits budget could look like under a properly designed ICHRA.

With traditional group coverage, the carrier sets the premium and the employer responds to that cost. With ICHRA, the employer establishes a defined reimbursement strategy and eligible employees obtain qualifying individual coverage.

That does not mean ICHRA will be less expensive. It means you may have another legitimate option to compare before committing to the next plan year.

One Employer. Two Approaches.

What Changes When You Compare Group Coverage With ICHRA?

The goal is not to force a change. It is to understand what each approach would mean for your budget and your employees.

Traditional Group Health Insurance

The carrier’s premium drives the starting point.

The employer chooses a group plan and determines how much of the premium the company will pay. At renewal, a new carrier rate can change both the employer’s cost and the employee’s share.

Individual Coverage HRA

The employer starts with a contribution strategy.

The employer establishes an ICHRA reimbursement amount under the plan design. Eligible employees then choose qualifying individual coverage available to them, subject to applicable eligibility, affordability and compliance rules.

When It Is Worth Running the Numbers

Three Situations That Should At Least Trigger an ICHRA Comparison

None of these guarantee savings. They are signals that relying on the renewal alone may leave an important alternative unexplored.

Your Renewal Is Getting Harder to Absorb

If maintaining the same employer contribution requires a materially larger benefits budget—or shifts more cost to employees—it may be worth modeling another way to fund coverage.

Your Workforce No Longer Fits One Market

Employees living in different areas may have very different individual-market choices. An ICHRA analysis can show whether those local options create a practical alternative to one group plan.

You Want More Intentional Budgeting

ICHRA allows the employer to design a defined reimbursement strategy for the plan year. That can create a different budgeting framework, while still requiring careful attention to affordability and compliance.

This Is Where the Answer Comes From

A Useful ICHRA Conversation Starts With Your Numbers.

Generic ICHRA savings claims are not enough. The comparison becomes meaningful only when it is built around your current plan and your actual workforce.

What you are paying now
Current group premiums and employer contribution.
What is changing at renewal
New premiums, benefits and employee costs.
Who is in your workforce
Employee ages, locations, family situations and permitted classes.
What is available to employees
Qualifying individual-market options in the areas where employees live.
What contribution strategy is realistic
A reimbursement structure designed around the employer’s objectives.
What compliance requires
Affordability, class structure, notices and other applicable requirements.

The Comparison We Want You to See

Current employer group costYour actual cost
Projected renewal costYour carrier renewal
Potential ICHRA contributionModeled for your workforce
ICHRA administrationIncluded in analysis
Individual-market premiumsReviewed by market
Affordability / ALE considerationsEvaluated before action
The first question is not “Will ICHRA save us money?”

The better question is: “What happens when we compare a realistic ICHRA strategy against the plan we already have?”

Once you can see both approaches, you can make a more informed decision.
A Comparison, Not a Commitment

See the Alternative Before You Decide.

You do not need to replace your group plan to explore ICHRA. You need enough information to know whether it deserves serious consideration.

1

Show Us Where You Are

We review your current plan, employer contribution, census and renewal.

2

See What Employees Could Access

We evaluate relevant individual-market coverage and employee circumstances.

3

Model a Realistic ICHRA

We develop a contribution scenario and account for administration and affordability.

4

Compare Before You Commit

You can evaluate the group renewal and ICHRA scenario side by side.

For Larger Employers, Affordability Is Part of the Decision

Applicable Large Employers are subject to ACA employer shared-responsibility requirements. An ICHRA contribution should not simply be set at an arbitrary low amount without evaluating affordability and potential employer-responsibility consequences.

The appropriate affordability analysis depends on the applicable plan year, employee circumstances and available safe harbors. That is one reason we believe the numbers should be reviewed before an employer treats ICHRA as a solution.

The Next Step Is Information

You Do Not Have to Choose ICHRA. First Find Out Whether It Deserves a Place at the Table.

Give us the basics about your current group plan and workforce. We can help you determine whether an ICHRA comparison is worth pursuing before your next benefits decision.

ICHRA Questions & Answers

ICHRA Frequently Asked Questions for Employers

Understand how ICHRA works, the 11 permitted employee classes, employer contributions, individual coverage, affordability and implementation before deciding whether it fits your business.

ICHRA Basics

What is an ICHRA?

An Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) is an employer-funded health benefit that can reimburse eligible employees, tax-free, for qualifying individual health insurance premiums and, depending on the plan design, certain eligible medical expenses.

Instead of the employer choosing one group health plan for all participating employees, eligible employees obtain their own qualifying individual coverage and receive reimbursements under the employer’s ICHRA terms.

How does an ICHRA work?

The employer establishes the ICHRA, determines which eligible employee classes will participate, sets the reimbursement allowance under the plan design, and provides required notices. Eligible employees obtain qualifying individual health insurance coverage or Medicare and substantiate coverage and eligible expenses before reimbursement.

Does ICHRA automatically save an employer money?

No. ICHRA should not be presented as an automatic cost-saving strategy. The result depends on the employer’s current group premiums, contribution levels, workforce, employee locations, individual-market premiums, administration costs, affordability requirements and ICHRA design.

Accurate Health Plans helps employers compare the numbers before making a change.

What is the difference between ICHRA and traditional group health insurance?

With traditional group health insurance, the employer generally selects one or more group plans and contributes toward the premiums. With ICHRA, the employer establishes a reimbursement benefit and eligible employees generally select their own qualifying individual health insurance.

Neither approach is automatically better. The economics and practical fit should be evaluated for the specific workforce.

What is the difference between ICHRA and QSEHRA?

Both can reimburse qualifying individual health coverage, but they operate under different rules. ICHRA is available to employers of any size and permits recognized employee classes. QSEHRA is limited to qualifying small employers, has federally established annual reimbursement limits, and follows a different eligibility and benefit framework.

Can a small business offer an ICHRA?

Yes. ICHRA can be offered by employers of various sizes, including small employers. Unlike QSEHRA, ICHRA is not limited to employers below the ACA Applicable Large Employer threshold.

The 11 ICHRA Employee Classes

What are the 11 ICHRA employee classes?

Federal ICHRA rules recognize the following 11 employee classes that may be used when designing eligibility:

  1. Full-time employees
  2. Part-time employees
  3. Seasonal employees
  4. Employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement
  5. Employees who have not satisfied a waiting period
  6. Non-resident aliens with no U.S.-based income
  7. Salaried employees
  8. Non-salaried employees
  9. Temporary employees of staffing firms
  10. Employees whose primary site of employment is in the same rating area
  11. A combination of two or more permitted classes above

Class definitions, minimum class-size requirements and other rules can apply, particularly when an employer offers a traditional group plan to one class and ICHRA to another.

Can an employer offer ICHRA to some employees and group health insurance to others?

Potentially, yes. An employer can use permitted employee classes to offer a traditional group health plan to certain classes and ICHRA to other classes, subject to applicable rules. An employer generally cannot give employees within the same class a choice between the traditional group plan and ICHRA.

What are the ICHRA minimum class-size requirements?

Minimum class-size rules can apply when certain employee classes are divided between a traditional group health plan and an ICHRA. Depending on employer size, the applicable minimum may be 10 employees, 10% of employees, or 20 employees. Not every class division is subject to the minimum, so the proposed structure should be reviewed before implementation.

Can an employer create its own employee classes?

Employers should use the employee classifications permitted under the federal ICHRA rules. Informal categories created simply to provide different benefits to selected employees may not satisfy those rules.

Can ICHRA work for employees in different states?

Yes. ICHRA can be worth evaluating for employers with geographically dispersed workforces because eligible employees generally obtain individual coverage available where they live. Premiums, carrier choices, provider networks and plan availability can vary substantially by market.

Can an employer use ICHRA for remote employees?

Potentially. The ICHRA rules include a class based on an employee’s primary site of employment in the same rating area. Employers should apply the regulatory class definitions rather than assume that the label “remote employee” by itself creates a separate ICHRA class.

Employer Contributions & Costs

Can an employer decide how much to contribute?

Yes. The employer establishes the reimbursement allowance under the ICHRA plan design. There is generally no federal ICHRA dollar contribution cap, although affordability, nondiscrimination and other requirements can affect how the benefit should be structured.

Is there a minimum employer contribution?

ICHRA itself generally does not impose a federal minimum dollar contribution. However, employers subject to ACA employer shared-responsibility provisions need to evaluate whether the offer is affordable under the applicable rules.

Is there a maximum employer contribution?

There is generally no federal dollar maximum for ICHRA contributions. The employer determines the reimbursement budget subject to the plan terms and applicable law.

Does the employer have to contribute the same amount for every employee?

Not necessarily. Permitted differences can be based on recognized employee classes and, within applicable rules, age and number of dependents. Employers should not arbitrarily assign different reimbursement amounts to individual employees without a permissible basis.

Can ICHRA contributions vary by age or family size?

Yes, within applicable ICHRA rules. Reimbursement amounts may be designed to vary based on age and number of dependents, subject to federal limitations and consistent application of the plan terms.

Can unused ICHRA allowances roll over?

An employer may design an ICHRA to allow unused amounts to carry forward, subject to applicable requirements. Whether rollover is available and how it operates should be specified in the plan documents.

Do unused ICHRA funds belong to the employee?

No. ICHRA is a reimbursement arrangement, not an employee-owned bank account. Employees are reimbursed for eligible expenses according to the plan terms, and unused amounts remain subject to the employer’s plan design.

Employee Coverage & Marketplace Questions

What health insurance can an employee use with an ICHRA?

Generally, the employee must be enrolled in qualifying individual health insurance coverage or Medicare that satisfies ICHRA requirements. Individual coverage may be obtained through the Health Insurance Marketplace or directly from an insurance carrier.

Can employees choose their own insurance company and plan?

Generally, yes, provided the coverage satisfies ICHRA requirements. This can give employees more choice, but premiums, provider networks, formularies and benefits can differ by location and carrier.

Can an employee use ICHRA with an ACA Marketplace plan?

Yes, qualifying individual Marketplace coverage can generally be used with ICHRA. However, an employee cannot receive ICHRA reimbursements and a Marketplace premium tax credit for the same coverage months.

What happens to an employee’s ACA premium tax credit?

An ICHRA offer can affect eligibility for Marketplace premium tax credits. Whether an employee may opt out of the ICHRA and qualify for a premium tax credit depends in part on whether the ICHRA offer is considered affordable under applicable ACA rules.

Can employees opt out of an ICHRA?

Generally, employees must have an opportunity to opt out of and waive future reimbursements at least annually and in certain other circumstances. The effect of opting out on Marketplace premium tax-credit eligibility depends on the applicable affordability rules.

Can ICHRA cover an employee’s spouse and children?

Yes, an employer can design an ICHRA to reimburse qualifying expenses for eligible dependents. The plan documents should define dependent eligibility and reimbursable expenses.

Can employees on Medicare participate in an ICHRA?

Yes. Medicare can satisfy the coverage requirement for ICHRA participation when applicable requirements are met. Medicare coordination and reimbursement rules should be considered when designing benefits for Medicare-eligible employees.

Can employees contribute their own money to an ICHRA?

No. ICHRA is employer-funded. If the cost of the employee’s coverage exceeds the available reimbursement, the employee is responsible for the remaining cost, subject to applicable rules regarding payment of individual-market premiums.

Can ICHRA reimburse expenses other than insurance premiums?

Potentially. An employer may design the ICHRA to reimburse qualifying individual insurance premiums and may also permit certain eligible medical expenses under Internal Revenue Code Section 213(d). The plan document determines which eligible expenses are reimbursable.

Are ICHRA reimbursements taxable to employees?

When an ICHRA is properly established and administered and applicable requirements are satisfied, qualifying reimbursements are generally excluded from the employee’s federal taxable income.

ACA, Affordability & Compliance

How is ICHRA affordability determined?

ICHRA affordability is determined under applicable ACA rules by comparing the employee’s required contribution for the relevant self-only individual-market benchmark coverage, after the ICHRA amount, with the applicable affordability standard. Special ICHRA rules and employer safe harbors may apply.

Because affordability percentages and market premiums can change, the calculation should be performed for the applicable plan year.

Does ICHRA satisfy the ACA employer mandate?

An ICHRA can be used by an Applicable Large Employer (ALE) as part of its strategy for satisfying ACA employer shared-responsibility requirements. Simply offering an ICHRA does not automatically establish compliance; eligibility, affordability and other requirements must be evaluated.

Is ICHRA subject to COBRA?

It can be. ICHRA is a group health plan, and COBRA continuation requirements can apply to employers subject to COBRA. Continuation requirements should be addressed as part of implementation and administration.

What notices must an employer provide?

ICHRA rules generally require eligible employees to receive a written notice explaining important information about the arrangement, including how the ICHRA can affect Marketplace premium tax-credit eligibility. Required timing and content should be incorporated into implementation.

Does ICHRA require formal plan documents?

Yes. An ICHRA is an employer-sponsored group health plan and should have appropriate plan documents, eligibility provisions, reimbursement procedures, notices and administrative processes. ERISA, ACA, COBRA, HIPAA and other requirements may apply depending on the employer and plan.

Who verifies that employees have qualifying health coverage?

Employees must substantiate qualifying individual coverage or Medicare for the periods for which reimbursements are provided. Employers often use an ICHRA administrator or third-party administrator to handle coverage substantiation, expense review and reimbursement administration.

How much administrative work does ICHRA create?

ICHRA requires ongoing eligibility management, coverage and expense substantiation, reimbursements, notices, plan documentation and compliance administration. Many employers use a third-party administrator rather than managing the process internally.

Starting or Switching to ICHRA

Can an employer switch from group health insurance to ICHRA?

Yes, if the transition is structured properly. Before terminating an existing group plan, the employer should compare costs, review individual-market availability, establish contribution amounts, evaluate employee classes and affordability, and coordinate implementation dates.

When can an employer start an ICHRA?

An ICHRA is not inherently limited to a January 1 start date. Implementation should be coordinated with individual-market enrollment opportunities, Special Enrollment Period rules, employee notices, the existing group-plan termination date and the employer’s plan year.

Is there a Special Enrollment Period when an employer starts an ICHRA?

Employees and dependents who become newly eligible for an ICHRA can generally qualify for a Special Enrollment Period to obtain individual health insurance. Timing should be coordinated so qualifying coverage is effective when needed.

Does an employer have to offer ICHRA to new employees immediately?

Not necessarily. Employees who have not satisfied a waiting period are one of the recognized ICHRA classes. Applicable eligibility and waiting-period requirements still need to be followed.

What happens when an employee leaves the company?

Generally, eligibility for future employer-funded reimbursements ends according to the plan terms, subject to applicable continuation-coverage requirements. Because the individual insurance policy is separate from the employer’s ICHRA, the employee may be able to keep that policy by paying the premium directly.

What information is needed to run an ICHRA comparison?

A meaningful comparison generally starts with an employee census and current plan information, including employee ages, ZIP codes or locations, family coverage needs, employment classifications, current premiums, employer contributions, renewal information and current plan structure.

This allows the comparison to use the employer’s actual workforce rather than a generic savings estimate.

How do I know whether ICHRA is right for my business?

The best starting point is a side-by-side analysis of the current group plan and a properly designed ICHRA scenario. Accurate Health Plans can evaluate the employee census, current costs, potential contribution strategy and individual-market conditions.

The objective is not to assume ICHRA is better. It is to determine which approach makes financial and practical sense for the employer and workforce.

Important: ICHRA rules are detailed and plan-specific. Employee classifications, affordability, notices, administration and other requirements should be reviewed for the employer’s actual circumstances before implementation.
Ready to See Your Numbers?

Find Out What ICHRA Could Look Like for Your Business.

Compare your current group health plan, renewal and workforce against a realistic ICHRA strategy before making a change.

Important: This page provides general educational information and does not guarantee savings. ICHRA costs and suitability depend on the employer’s workforce, individual-market premiums, plan design, contribution strategy, administration, affordability and applicable law. This information is not tax or legal advice.